Concert review: Miloš Karadaglic turns in fine South Florida debut with Cleveland Orchestra

11.15.14
Giancarlo Guerrero
Miami Herald

By Lawrence Budmen 

While the program for Friday’s opening concert of the Cleveland Orchestra’s annual Miami residency was lightweight, the evening of orchestral showpieces displayed the ensemble at its considerable best. 

Still, the concert’s most significant event was the South Florida debut of guitarist Miloš Karadaglic, who turned an oft-played warhorse into a fresh listening experience.

A major recording contract with Deutsche Grammophon and international touring have catapulted the handsome Montenegro-born guitarist into the spotlight. More than merely an easily promotable celebrity, Karadaglic is an exceptional musician.

Joaquin Rodrigo’s Concierto de Aranjuez has been played thousands of times since its 1940 premiere. (Interestingly the Clevelanders gave the American premiere of the score in 1959 with Ray de la Torre.) Yet when played with the artistry lavished on it by Karadaglic, however, the piece can still delight the ear. Relate

The opening chords and strumming were projected with clarity and admirable restraint. Karadaglic breezed through the runs and elegant ornaments, his technique rock-solid. The famous Adagio was finely etched, sensual and romantic without heaviness. Karadaglic’s fleet, energetic reading of the finale captured the brightness of the off-kilter melodies.

Discreetly amplified to carry in the vast spaces of the Arsht Center’s Knight Concert Hall, Karadaglic’s Greg Smallman guitar was a fine instrument with particularly deep and distinct bass notes. His wonderfully virile rendition managed to clear away the clichés and mannerisms that afflict many performances of the Aranjuez.

Giancarlo Guerrero, principal guest conductor for the orchestra’s Miami residency, is an expert accompanist. He deftly blended and balanced Rodrigo’s piquant wind and string writing without overpowering his soloist. Rhythms were crisp and snappy, the unison violins sounded lustrous and brash trumpet interjections in the finale perked up the ears. One can only wonder why Karadaglic’s fine performance was accorded only one curtain call by an audience that loudly cheered the flashier orchestral scores.

Like Gustav Holst (composer of The Planets, which Guerrero led in Miami last season), Ottorino Respighi anticipated the modern motion picture soundtrack with his extravagant orchestral tone poems. The Fountains of Rome, the first and most artful of Respighi’s Roman trilogy, displayed the evening’s largest orchestral complement with two harps, celesta, expanded strings, brass and percussion and eight double basses filling the stage.

Guerrero managed to bring out the poetry amid Respighi’s wide-screen panorama of orchestral colors. The soft string sounds and evocative wind tints with celesta exquisitely blended into the orchestral fabric evoked night turning to dawn in the opening portrait of the Villa Giulia fountain. Delicate pianissimos and fine blends of tolling bells, celesta and harps over whispered strings encapsulated the Technicolor sunset of the Villa Medici finale.

The program opened and closed with two portraits by Russian composers of street music and dance in foreign lands. One horn blooper aside, Tchaikovsky’s Capriccio Italien featured powerhouse brass, Guerrero ratcheting up the final tarantella to fever pitch.

The orchestra’s superb first chairs shone to splendid effect in Rimsky-Korsako’s Capriccio Espagnol with flawless clarinet scales and superb solo moments from cello, harp, horn, flute and English horn. Concertmaster William Preucil managed to top his colleagues, bringing agility and virtuosity to the numerous violin solos and cadenzas. Opening at a brisk pace, Guerrero rendered the Latin-tinged melodies and dance rhythms at full thrust.

That was a very interesting opener. I don't care about the greatness of Mozart's Piano Concertos: they are sufficiently brilliant to take care of themselves. I do care about the Sinfonia Concertante, because it is one of the greatest, most perfect of all musical works, and I include Mozart's concertos and the last symphonies.

Yet it gets sidelined. There are issues. You need two soloists, a violin and a viola. But they are part of the orchestra: it's not a virtuoso display case; it's more symphonic than that. So do you employ two star soloists, or find another way? Runnicles' solution was perfect: he used Laura Samuel, leader of the SSO, and Scott Dickinson, principal viola, both extremely experienced chamber musicians, highlighted by the intimacy of their duologues, and both consummate orchestral musicians and leaders, through whom Runnicles could emphasise the symphonic integrity of the work. Fabulous playing from both, and from all. So simple; so perfect.

Not far behind it, on the endless road towards veracity, was Runnicles' and the SSO's Beethoven Ninth, where intellectual argument and drama, rather than atmospherics, dominated the first movement. Where long-range propulsion drove the Scherzo. Where sustained, expressive fluidity characterised the great slow movement, and where, when it took form and broke through, the visionary melodiousness of the finale was transcendent, with impressively rounded singing from the soloists and, not a shout in sight, the Edinburgh Festival Chorus.