Recent News
Colin Currie
A striking performance from percussionist Colin Currie
Boston Globe
Colin Currie
Colin Currie brings probing mind and energetic technique to Pickman Hall
Boston Classical Review
Shai Wosner
Beethoven: Complete Cello Sonatas and Variations CD review – here's how to make Beethoven's huge structures work
The Guardian
Johannes Debus, Patricia Racette
A riveting Racette ignites in Met’s “Salome”
New York Classical Review
Wynton Marsalis, James Conlon, Giancarlo Guerrero, Miguel Harth-Bedoya, Eric Jacobsen, Mariss Jansons, Ludovic Morlot, David Robertson, Gene Scheer, Gil Shaham, Yo-Yo Ma, Branford Marsalis, Mason Bates, Silk Road Ensemble , Nashville Symphony , St. Louis Symphony Orchestra , The Knights , Patti LuPone, Georgia Jarman, Ian Bostridge, Nathan Gunn, Thomas Hampson, Lucas Meachem, Luca Pisaroni
2017 Grammy Nominees
Grammy Awards
JoAnn Falletta
How the Buffalo Philharmonic Orchestra Hit Its Stride
New York State of Opportunity
Colin Currie
Colin Currie provides the highlight in New World’s program of contemporary German music
South Florida Classical Review
Review: VOCES8's "Winter"
Shai Wosner
Review: Shai Wosner's Haydn/Ligeti
The TEN Tenors
The TEN Tenors Launch Holiday Tour, Support St Jude Children’s Hospital

News archive »

David Zinman leads the New York Philharmonic in lively but aggressive Beethoven

Alisa Weilerstein

By Ronni Reich

There was no brisk passage that went without virtuoso speed, no accent that wasn’t firmly underlined and no performance that sounded less than fully engaged at the New Jersey Performing Arts Center on Friday.

For the New York Philharmonic’s annual NJPAC appearance, David Zinman arrived at the helm of the orchestra as part of “The Modern Beethoven” festival, in which he is sharing his distinctive interpretations that stick closely to original manuscript markings. Yet while the performances of Beethoven’s Symphony No. 8 and Beethoven Symphony No. 4 were lively, they glossed over some of the charm and lyricism inherent in the works and there was some slapdash playing, particularly from the horns.

The Eighth Symphony began with a strong gust of energy, the short opening theme announcing itself decisively. In seesawing motives that followed, the orchestra leaned into low notes with endearing gruffness. Zinman culled transparency textures and the orchestra maintained remarkable dexterity.

The simple elegance of the second movement, shot through with unexpected jabbing figures, was effective. So was the fourth movement opening, which featured soft, rapid violin beating that called to mind hummingbird wings as well as enjoyably big, not-too-proper contrasts.

The fleet, urgent rendering of the finale drew welcome attention to the amount of ground the music covers in a short period of time. Still, the music sometimes seemed overly strong-armed, with the arched, airy melodies that balance the action dispatched abruptly and hastily.

Throughout the Philharmonic’s festival, 20th century concertos are being presented between the main composer’s symphonies. Far more than a palate cleanser, Barber’s Cello Concerto with the authoritative Alisa Weilerstein as the soloist became the high point of the concert. Weilerstein and the orchestra were especially vivid as they captured the violent angularity of the piece, which vacillates among war cry, plangent or vulnerable song and feverish outbursts.

Weilerstein’s attention to timbre, organic phrasing and exquisite control through any technical obstacle amazed. She dug into anxiously repetitive and deep, rough, vigorous episodes, and also employed a gorgeous singing tone--warm, well projected, velvety-- when appropriate.

In the Fourth Symphony, Zinman’s aggressive approach to highlighting each slashing chord or emphasized note sometimes broke up the flow of the work. There was character in moments that had teasing, thunderous or joyful qualities, and the smoothness of the playing and the taut ensemble of the second movement impressed. But the quicksilver finale suffered, with rigidity in its speed that sometimes made for underwhelming sound quality.

Zinman’s Beethoven has become a touchstone interpretation of the repertoire, and his influence on performance practice is significant. Whether one agrees entirely with his choices or not, they are certainly thought-provoking and should be of interest. The program with Weilerstein will be repeated tonight at Avery Fisher Hall, with Beethoven’s First and Third Symphonies in performance March 15-20.